Annexure
B
VERIFICATION/SCRUTINY
OF OROP TABLES SENT BY PCDA(P) ALLAHABAD FOR PBOR
A Discrepancy in rates of Army (PBOR)
1. Casting errors in CST (Comparative
Statement of Tables) for Army
(i) In QS 7 years of Sep ‘X’ rate of Air
Force @ Rs 7145 (min & max) has not been included in CST though rate was
taken in final tables.
(ii) In QS 20 years Sep ‘Y’ rate of Army @ 6047 (min) taken in CST
but data if Army shows @ 5480
(iii) In QS 15.5. Sep ‘Y’ rate of Army @ 6870
(max) taken for CST but data of Army shows @ 7050.
(iv) In QS 19 years Naik ‘Y’
rate of Army @ 7435 (max) taken in CST but in data of Army shows @ 7440
(v)
In QS 29.5
years Sub ‘Y’ rate of Army @13298 (max) taken in CST but in data of Army shows
@ 13295.
Annexure C
Error in
calculation of pension in respect of Regular Commissioned Officers
Note: PCDA
indicates calculated by PCDA (P); HQ indicates calculated by O/o CGDA
For ease of reference the Landscape setup
has been changed to Portrait by me
Rank
|
Major
|
Lt Col
|
Col (TS)
|
Col
|
||||
QS
|
PCDA
|
HQ
|
PCDA
|
HQ
|
PCDA
|
HQ
|
PCDA
|
HQ
|
14
|
||||||||
14.5
|
||||||||
15
|
21530
|
23040
|
||||||
15.5
|
21530
|
23040
|
||||||
16
|
21530
|
23040
|
||||||
16.5
|
21530
|
23040
|
||||||
17
|
21530
|
23040
|
||||||
18
|
21530
|
23040
|
||||||
19
|
21530
|
23040
|
||||||
19.5
|
21530
|
23040
|
30014
|
29167
|
||||
20
|
21530
|
23040
|
||||||
20.5
|
21530
|
23040
|
||||||
21
|
21530
|
23040
|
||||||
21.5
|
21530
|
23040
|
||||||
22
|
21530
|
23815
|
||||||
22.5
|
21530
|
23815
|
||||||
23
|
21530
|
23815
|
||||||
23.5
|
21530
|
23815
|
||||||
24
|
21530
|
23815
|
||||||
24.5
|
21530
|
23815
|
||||||
25
|
21530
|
23815
|
||||||
25.5
|
21530
|
23815
|
32813
|
32775
|
||||
26
|
21530
|
23815
|
32813
|
32780
|
||||
26.5
|
21530
|
23815
|
33225
|
33850
|
||||
27
|
21530
|
23815
|
33225
|
33850
|
||||
28
|
21530
|
23815
|
33225
|
33850
|
||||
28.5
|
21530
|
23815
|
33225
|
33850
|
||||
29
|
21530
|
23815
|
33225
|
33850
|
35325
|
35233
|
||
30
|
21530
|
23815
|
33225
|
33850
|
||||
30.5
|
21530
|
23815
|
33225
|
33850
|
||||
31
|
21530
|
23815
|
34393
|
33925
|
||||
31.5
|
21530
|
23815
|
||||||
32
|
21530
|
23815
|
||||||
32.5
|
21530
|
23815
|
||||||
33
|
21530
|
23815
|
||||||
Rank
|
Brig
|
Maj Gen
|
Lt Gen
|
Lt Gen (HAG+)
|
||||
QS
|
PCDA
|
HQ
|
PCDA
|
HQ
|
PCDA
|
HQ
|
PCDA
|
HQ
|
14
|
||||||||
14.5
|
||||||||
15
|
||||||||
15.5
|
||||||||
16
|
||||||||
16.5
|
||||||||
17
|
||||||||
18
|
||||||||
19
|
||||||||
19.5
|
||||||||
20
|
||||||||
20.5
|
||||||||
21
|
||||||||
21.5
|
||||||||
22
|
||||||||
22.5
|
||||||||
23
|
||||||||
23.5
|
||||||||
24
|
||||||||
24.5
|
||||||||
25
|
||||||||
25.5
|
||||||||
26
|
34799
|
34904
|
34799
|
34904
|
34799
|
34904
|
34799
|
34904
|
26.5
|
||||||||
27
|
||||||||
28
|
||||||||
28.5
|
||||||||
29
|
||||||||
30
|
||||||||
30.5
|
||||||||
31
|
37576
|
37636
|
||||||
31.5
|
37705
|
37798
|
38182
|
38218
|
||||
32
|
37589
|
37601
|
38304
|
38315
|
38788
|
38800
|
||
32.5
|
38176
|
38182
|
38902
|
38908
|
39394
|
39400
|
||
33
|
||||||||
Error in
calculation of pension in respect of Doctors of AMC/ADC & RVC including
Doctors of Navy and Air Force
*PCDA indicates PCDA (P)
Rank
|
Col (TS)
|
Col
|
Brig
|
Maj Gen
|
Lt Gen
|
||||||
QS
|
PCDA*
|
HQ
|
PCDA
|
HQ
|
PCDA
|
HQ
|
PCDA
|
HQ
|
PCDA
|
HQ
|
|
0.5
|
|||||||||||
1
|
|||||||||||
1.5
|
23652
|
23646
|
23652
|
23646
|
23652
|
23646
|
|||||
2
|
|||||||||||
2.5
|
24383
|
24377
|
24383
|
24377
|
24383
|
24377
|
|||||
3
|
|||||||||||
3.5
|
25137
|
25130
|
25137
|
25130
|
25137
|
25130
|
|||||
4
|
|||||||||||
4.5
|
25914
|
25907
|
25914
|
25907
|
25914
|
25907
|
|||||
5
|
|||||||||||
5.5
|
26715
|
26708
|
26715
|
26708
|
26715
|
26708
|
|||||
6
|
|||||||||||
6.5
|
27540
|
27533
|
27540
|
27533
|
27540
|
27533
|
|||||
7
|
|||||||||||
7.5
|
28391
|
28384
|
28391
|
28384
|
28391
|
28384
|
|||||
8
|
|||||||||||
8.5
|
29269
|
29261
|
29269
|
29261
|
29269
|
29261
|
|||||
9
|
29714
|
29713
|
29714
|
29713
|
29714
|
29713
|
|||||
9.5
|
30173
|
30165
|
30173
|
30165
|
30173
|
30165
|
|||||
10
|
30632
|
30631
|
30632
|
30631
|
30632
|
30631
|
|||||
10.5
|
31106
|
31097
|
31106
|
31097
|
31106
|
31097
|
|||||
11
|
31579
|
31578
|
31579
|
31578
|
31579
|
31578
|
|||||
11.5
|
32067
|
32058
|
32067
|
32058
|
32067
|
32058
|
|||||
12
|
32555
|
32554
|
32555
|
32554
|
32555
|
32554
|
|||||
12.5
|
33058
|
33049
|
33058
|
33049
|
33058
|
33049
|
|||||
13
|
33561
|
33560
|
33561
|
33560
|
33561
|
33560
|
|||||
13.5
|
34080
|
34071
|
34080
|
34071
|
34080
|
34071
|
|||||
14
|
|||||||||||
14.5
|
35133
|
35124
|
35133
|
35124
|
35133
|
35124
|
|||||
15
|
|||||||||||
15.5
|
36219
|
36210
|
36219
|
36210
|
36219
|
36210
|
|||||
16
|
|||||||||||
16.5
|
37338
|
37329
|
37338
|
37329
|
37338
|
37329
|
|||||
17
|
|||||||||||
17.5
|
38492
|
38483
|
38492
|
38483
|
38492
|
38483
|
|||||
18
|
|||||||||||
18.5
|
39682
|
39673
|
39682
|
39673
|
39682
|
39673
|
|||||
19
|
|||||||||||
19.5
|
40909
|
40899
|
40909
|
40899
|
40909
|
40899
|
|||||
20
|
|||||||||||
20.5
|
|||||||||||
21
|
42332
|
42163
|
42332
|
42163
|
42332
|
42163
|
42332
|
42163
|
42332
|
42163
|
|
Errors in
calculation of pension for MNS Officers
Rank
|
Col
|
Brig
|
Maj Gen
|
|||
QS
|
PCDA
|
HQ
|
PCDA
|
HQ
|
PCDA
|
HQ
|
0.5
|
11039
|
11670
|
||||
1
|
11207
|
11847
|
||||
1.5
|
11380
|
12030
|
||||
2
|
11553
|
12213
|
||||
2.5
|
11732
|
12402
|
||||
3
|
11910
|
12590
|
||||
3.5
|
12094
|
12785
|
||||
4
|
12278
|
12979
|
||||
4.5
|
12468
|
13180
|
||||
5
|
12657
|
13380
|
||||
5.5
|
12853
|
13587
|
||||
6
|
13048
|
13793
|
||||
6.5
|
13250
|
14006
|
||||
7
|
13451
|
14219
|
||||
7.5
|
13659
|
14439
|
||||
8
|
13867
|
14658
|
||||
8.5
|
14081
|
14885
|
||||
9
|
14295
|
15111
|
||||
9.5
|
14516
|
15345
|
||||
10
|
14737
|
15578
|
||||
10.5
|
14965
|
15819
|
||||
11
|
15192
|
16059
|
||||
11.5
|
15427
|
16307
|
||||
12
|
15661
|
16555
|
||||
12.5
|
15903
|
16811
|
||||
13
|
16145
|
17066
|
||||
13.5
|
16395
|
17330
|
||||
14
|
16644
|
17593
|
||||
15
|
17158
|
18137
|
||||
15.5
|
17423
|
18417
|
||||
16
|
17688
|
18697
|
||||
16.5
|
17962
|
18986
|
||||
17
|
18235
|
19275
|
||||
17.5
|
18517
|
19573
|
||||
18
|
18978
|
19871
|
||||
18.5
|
19089
|
20178
|
||||
19
|
19379
|
20485
|
||||
20
|
19978
|
21118
|
||||
20.5
|
20287
|
21445
|
||||
21
|
20595
|
21771
|
||||
21.5
|
20638
|
20595
|
20638
|
20595
|
20638
|
22108
|
22
|
20914
|
22444
|
||||
22.5
|
21389
|
22791
|
||||
23
|
21864
|
23138
|
||||
23.5
|
21338
|
21335
|
21338
|
21335
|
22340
|
23496
|
24
|
22815
|
23853
|
||||
24.5
|
23290
|
24222
|
||||
25
|
23766
|
24590
|
||||
25.5
|
21988
|
21805
|
21988
|
21805
|
24241
|
24970
|
26
|
24716
|
25350
|
||||
26.5
|
25192
|
25742
|
||||
27
|
22250
|
22733
|
25667
|
26133
|
||
27.5
|
22582
|
22550
|
22582
|
22915
|
26142
|
26537
|
28
|
22613
|
23269
|
26617
|
26941
|
||
28.5
|
22963
|
23623
|
27093
|
27358
|
||
29
|
23312
|
23988
|
27568
|
27774
|
||
29.5
|
23672
|
24353
|
28043
|
28203
|
||
30
|
24032
|
24730
|
28519
|
28632
|
||
30.5
|
24404
|
25106
|
28994
|
29075
|
||
31
|
24775
|
25494
|
29469
|
29517
|
||
31.5
|
25158
|
25882
|
29945
|
29973
|
||
32
|
25541
|
26282
|
30420
|
30429
|
||
32.5
|
26936
|
26682
|
30895
|
30900
|
||
33
|
26330
|
27095
|
31370
|
31370
|
||
Note:
Rate for Brigadier at 33 years has been arrived at by reducing the available
rate at 37.5 years.
Errors in
calculation of pension for MNS Officers
Table has been edited to give amounts for
the QS indicated
Rank
|
Lt
|
Capt
|
||
QS
|
PCDA
|
HQ
|
PCDA
|
HQ
|
17 to 17.5
|
Amounts Not indicated
|
|||
18
|
14216
|
15175
|
||
18.5
|
14436
|
15175
|
||
19
|
14655
|
15175
|
||
19.5
|
14882
|
15175
|
||
20
|
15108
|
15175
|
||
20.5 to 26
|
Amounts Not indicated
|
|||
26.5
|
15627
|
15175
|
||
27
|
15627
|
15175
|
||
27.7 to 33
|
Amounts Not Incicated
|
|||
Calculations
Errors in Final Tables
In the
following places calculation errors observed in final tables during scrutiny,
same should be recalculated, rechecked and modified accordingly
[A] Service Pension (PBOR – Regular Army)
QS
|
Rank
|
Group
|
As per calculations
in HQ office
|
Rate proposed by
PCDA (P) Allahabad
|
15.5 to 19.5 years
|
Naik
|
Y
|
7275
|
7278
|
QS
|
Rank
|
Group
|
As per calculations
in HQ office
|
Rate proposed by
PCDA (P) Allahabad
|
15.5 to 19.5 years
|
Hony Havildar
|
Y
|
7275
|
7278
|
QS
|
Rank
|
As per calculations
in HQ office
|
Rate proposed by
PCDA (P) Allahabad
|
|
26.5
|
Hony Lt
|
-
|
14799
|
15627
|
27
|
Hony Lt
|
15336
|
15627
|
[B] TA (PBOR)
Service Pension
QS
|
Rank
|
As per calculations
in HQ office
|
Rate proposed by
PCDA (P) Allahabad
|
|
9
|
Hav
|
6246
|
6257
|
|
9.5
|
Hav
|
6246
|
6257
|
|
10
|
Hav
|
6246
|
6364
|
QS
|
Rank
|
As per calculations
in HQ office
|
Rate proposed by
PCDA (P) Allahabad
|
|
3.5
|
Subedar
|
7478
|
7468
|
QS
|
Rank
|
As per calculations
in HQ office
|
Rate proposed by
PCDA (P) Allahabad
|
|
23 to 24
|
Subedar
|
11533
|
11386
|
|
24.5 to 26
|
Subedar
|
12330
|
11386
|
|
26.5 & above
|
Subedar
|
12660
|
11386
|
QS
|
Rank
|
As per calculations
in HQ office
|
Rate proposed by
PCDA (P) Allahabad
|
|
16
|
Sub Major
|
11386
|
11484
|
|
16.5
|
Sub Major
|
11484
|
11581
|
QS
|
Rank
|
As per calculations
in HQ office
|
Rate proposed by
PCDA (P) Allahabad
|
|
24.5 to 25.5
|
Subedar
|
12330
|
11581
|
|
26 to 29 & above
|
Subedar
|
12660
|
12225
|
[C] Family Pensions, Disability Element & War Injury
Elements (PBOR): The corresponding rates of
above mentioned QS and ranks in family pensions and disability element &
war injury elements of PBOR will also be corrected accordingly.
[D] Family Pensions, Disability Element & War Injury
Elements (PBOR): There are Re One (01)
differences in many places due to rounding off of pension which will get
checked and ensured that only once rounding off will be given in calculation.
Annexure D
Revised Air Force
Data
S No.
|
QS
|
Rank
|
Group
|
Min
|
Max
|
Action by JCDA (AF)
|
Remarks
|
1
|
7
|
AC/LAC
|
X
|
7145
|
7145
|
Checked & found correct
|
|
2
|
15
|
AC/LAC
|
X
|
7845 rectified as 7450
|
8315 rectified as 8180
|
MACP granted, hence data removed from chart
|
Same has been confirmed by DAV in writing
|
3
|
15
|
AC/LAC
|
Y
|
7605 rectified as 6965
|
MACP granted, hence data removed from chart
|
Same has been confirmed by DAV in writing
|
|
4
|
6.5
|
CPL
|
X
|
7290
|
7290
|
Read 7350 for Min & Max
|
|
5
|
6.5
|
CPL
|
Y
|
6530
|
6530
|
Checked & found correct
|
|
6
|
8.5
|
CPL
|
X
|
8070
|
8070
|
Checked & found correct
|
|
7
|
11.5
|
CPL
|
Y
|
7275
|
8275
|
Checked & found correct
|
|
8
|
17
|
CPL
|
X
|
8770
|
9230
|
For 0230 read as 8770
|
9230 is CPL with MACP
|
9
|
17.5
|
CPL
|
X
|
9305
|
Min & Max data deleted as
same is for CPL MACP
|
||
10
|
19.5
|
CPL
|
X
|
9245
|
Min & Max data deleted as
same is for CPL MACP
|
||
11
|
20
|
CPL
|
Y
|
8295
|
Min & Max data deleted as
same is for CPL MACP
|
||
12
|
17
|
SGT
|
X
|
10670
|
For 10670 Read 9685
|
||
13
|
17.5
|
JWO
|
X
|
10940
|
Checked and found correct
|
||
14
|
19.5
|
SGT
|
Y
|
9020 rectified as 8390
|
Checked and found correct
|
||
15
|
20
|
SGT
|
X
|
10275 rectified as 9245
|
Checked and found correct
|
||
16
|
21
|
SGT
|
Y
|
5370 rectified as 8185
|
8400
|
Checked and found correct
|
|
17
|
23
|
JWO
|
X
|
11365
|
Checked and found correct
|
||
18
|
25.5
|
JWO
|
X
|
11365
|
Checked and found correct
|
||
19
|
35
|
JWO
|
X
|
11545 rectified as 12530
|
Checked and found correct
|
||
20
|
18
|
WO
|
Y
|
10840
|
10840
|
Removed being direct entry
|
Trade: GTI Sports
|
21
|
19
|
WO
|
X
|
12410
|
12410
|
Removed being direct entry
|
Trade: EDN Inst
|
22
|
22.5
|
WO
|
X
|
11835
|
Checked and found correct
|
||
23
|
26
|
WO
|
X
|
12430
|
Checked and found correct
|
||
24
|
29
|
MWO
|
X
|
14395
|
14395
|
Removed being direct entry
|
Trade: EDN Inst
|
25
|
32.5
|
MWO
|
Y
|
12285
|
12285
|
Checked and found correct
|
--------------Original
Message-----------
From: Ravin Agarwal
<ravinagarwal11@yahoo.com>
Date: Jan 11, 2016
Subject: FW: OROP table
& data in r/o TA/DSC (PBOR) & EC/SS& MNS (CO)
To: Rajesh Kumar Gupta CGDA
Office guptarajesh.cgda@nic.in,
Rajesh Gupta rajeshcgda@gmail.com
On Saturday January 9, 2016
3:03 PM, Arvind Kumar Malviya arvind_malviya.cgda@nic.in
wrote
Dear Sir
The
tables of TA & DSC (PBOR) and tables of Commissioned Officers are attached
herewith. The data and CST are also attached.
As
discussed yesterday with PCDA (P), the protection of circular 500 has been
withdrawn in retiring pension. But the same is still given in other types of
pensions as given in circular 503, 542 etc. Please confirm whether these
protection will also be withdrawn or not.
The tables of regular PBOR
are under re-modification due to receipt of amended data from Jt CDA (AF) on
9.1.2016 at 1.25 pm.
Regards
A. K. Malviya
* * * * * *
On Monday, January 11, 2016
10:34 AM, Rajesh Kumar Gupta guptarajesh.cgda@nic.in
wrote:
Dear Sir,
With
reference to clarification sought, it was decided that the protection
previously applicable only for one category of pensioners (pre-2006) is not to
be incorporated in the tables as it will affect the entitlement of other
category of pensioners (post 2006). The protection already allowed in the rate
of pensions is not being withdrawn but the tables on OROP is being prepared
independently from all existing orders
by taking into account average pension of 2013 retirees.
Hence, equal treatment has
to be allowed for all kind of pensioners whether are in receipt of service,
family or disability pension.
May be advised not to
incorporate the protection with existing rates of pension in the tables of OROP
for family pension and disability element also.
Sir, please check the reply
and forward to Malviya sir if found appropriate for needful.
With regards
Rajesh.
* * * * *
Jai Hind
